Thursday, April 19, 2007

Stealing Money meant for Children – what happened next?

Stealing Money meant for Children – what happened next?

The reader may remember this story circulated by CHRI a few months ago. By way of recollecting in brief this is what had happened –

Mr. Vishwajeet Maitee of Katni district in Madhya Pradesh had filed an RTI application seeking information about the rates at which first aid kits were procured for use in the teaching centres established under the Indus Child Labour Project. This project, aimed at rehabilitating rescued child labourers by providing them with education and vocational skills, is sponsored by the International Labour Organisation. This project is being implemented in five districts including Katni in MP.

The RTI intervention revealed gross overpricing of the medical kits amounting to a loss of more than Rs. 100,000 for the project. Subsequently spot checks conducted by Dr. Rakesh Ranjan of Sandhan, Katni as to the contents of these kits revealed that the supplies were of poor quality.

While this story was being read and discussed in cyberspace, Dr. Rakesh Ranjan decided to take the matter right up to the ILO. He wrote to the concerned officers at ILO attaching copies of all documents and bills collected as evidence. The project managers wrote back to the District Collector Katni requesting an inquiry into the matter. The Collector issued a show cause notice to the Project Director of Indus based in Katni. Subsequent proceedings led to the recovery of Rs. 80,000/- from the supplier. A small victory against corruption indeed.

The supplier contends in his defence that he has to pay bribes in order to secure a supply contract in his favour despite a competitive bidding process followed by the public authorities. Hence the overpricing of the medical kits. RTI activists in MP are now formulating strategies to unmask corrupt officials. This is a hard task as very often favours given to officials do not leave a paper trail.

But there’s more on RTI interventions relating to the Indus Project coming in our next despatch.

Compiled by Venkatesh Nayak for CHRI, New Delhi.

(Mr. Vishwajeet Maitee is an active member of the Madhya Pradesh Suchana Adhikar Abhiyan. Dr. Rakesh Ranjan runs Sandhan - an NGO based in Katni and coordinates the Madhya Pradesh Suchana Adhikaar Abhiyan a state-wide network of CSOs and activists involved in public education, advocacy and monitoring of the RTI Act. Dr. Ranjan also collaborates with CHRI's Access to Information Programme.)

Stealing Money meant for Children

Stealing Money meant for Children

The Madhya Pradesh State Government runs the Indus Child Labor Project funded by the International Labour Organization (ILO). The main aim of this project is to provide primary education to erstwhile child labourers. It also provides for their professional skill development. This three-year project is being implemented in five districts namely, Katni, Jabalpur, Mandla, Satna and Sagar since January 2004.

Indus Project is implemented through a registered society - National Child Labour Project (NCLP) which receives monies from ILO through the State Government and makes disbursements. The District Collector is the President of NCLP and the District Labour Officer is its secretary. Five Project Directors are appointed for overseeing the execution of the project. In Katni district alone a sum of Rs 31,80,750 has been earmarked for the execution of this project.

Rumours about corruption in the implementation of Indus Project have existed since its inception. But citizens had no means of proving the same as they did not have access to any documentation before the central RTI Act came into force. MP had passed its own RTI Act in 2002 but it was not implemented as the rules had not been made yet. When citizens tried to apply for information under the Departmental RTI orders issued by the State Government in 1997, information was denied on the ground that these orders did not apply to UN sponsored projects.

An RTI activist working in MP along with the Madhya Pradesh Suchana Adhikar Abhiyan, got to know of the widespread corruption in the Indus project. He decided to file an application under the RTI Act to find out the truth.

He filed his application with the PIO of the Indus Project Office in Katni on December 7, 2005. He asked for the following information -

1) The number of first aid kits bought for Teaching Centres being run under the Project in Katni;

2) The rate at which the kits were bought

3) An inventory of the contents of the kit

4) A copy of the proactive disclosure under Sec 4(1)(b).


He received the information within 17 days after payment of additional fees. The Public Information Officer informed him in writing that 40 first aid kits were bought at the rate of Rs. 3,500/- per kit. These kits were bought in August 2005 and supplied to 40 Training Centres in Katni in September. This data alone did not reveal any evidence of corruption.

He decided to ascertain the prevalent market rates for the first aid kit. He sought quotations from the local distributors of three companies (one Indian and two multinational) which sold similar kits. The quotations received were as follows -

Paras Pharmaceuticals (Indore based company) - Rs. 760/-

Alembic Pharmaceuticals (olkata based MNC) - Rs. 930/-

Glaxo Smithkline Beecham (another well known MNC) - Rs. 970/-

The implementing agency spent Rs. 1,40,000/- for buying 40 kits @ Rs. 3,500/- per kit through an open tender process where the contract for supply is awarded to the lowest bidder. Had the agency bought the kits from the open market from the most expensive distributor - Glaxo - it would have had to spend only Rs. 38,800/- It is crystal clear - somebody has pocketed more than one lakh rupees in the procurement process. There are 200 Indus Teaching Centres in MP. If corruption in procurement is the prevalent norm in all five districts the scandal could run into several lakhs of rupees.

Dr. Rakesh Ranjan of Sandhan Katni who is also the Coordinator of the Madhya Pradesh Suchana Adhikar Abhiyan decided to investigate the matter further. Along with a journalist from Dainik Jagran, he visited 10 Teaching Centres to check the kits on the spot. They were astonished to find that noe of the kits displayed any company logo. In three centres the kits were found to be empty and the contents of seven kits in other centres were of cheaper quality than that mentioned in the quality specifications. This scandal was highlighted in the local newspapers. But no action has been initiated by the district administration so far. Dr. Ranjan will be sending a complaint along with documentation of his findings to ILO and the vigilance authorities of MP Government.

Some people feel no shame or remorse for stealing money meant for underprivileged children.

Compiled by Venkatesh Nayak for CHRI, New Delhi.

(Dr. Rakesh Ranjan runs Sandhan - an NGO based in Katni and coordinates the Madhya Pradesh Suchana Adhikaar Abhiyan a state-wide network of CSOs and activists involved in public education, advocacy and monitoring of the RTI Act. Dr. Ranjan also collaborates with CHRI's Access to Information Programme.)

Monday, March 12, 2007

Kaayam churna or Gaayab churna?

Kaayam churna or Gaayab churna?
RTI unearths corruption in the procurement of medical supplies in a PSU


Should you happen to casually walk into a primary health centre in any of India’s small towns what kinds of medicines would you expect to find stocked on its shelves? Life saving medicines for treating snake bites and rabies? Paracetamol and antibiotics for those suffering from some water borne infection? Vaccines for inoculating babies from life-threatening diseases? Tablets and injections for those suffering from high blood pressure or diabetes? Think again. If you happened to visit one of the primary health centres run by the South Eastern Coal Fields Ltd. you might just stumble upon hair oils, massage oils and even, believe it or not, aphrodisiacs euphemistically called vitality restoring tonics. Or perhaps you would find them only on paper – shown as ayurvedic medicines purchased at exorbitant rates.

Rumours of corruption in SECL are neither rare nor recent. Until the coming of the RTI Act people had no way of verifying these allegations spoken in hushed tones. After all SECL has been proudly announcing on its website its unique record of earning profits ever since its inception in 1986. This public sector undertaking is the single largest producer of coal amongst the eight subsidiaries of Coal India Ltd. In 2005-06 alone SECL extracted 83.02 million tons of coal from its mines situated in the districts of Shahdol, Umaria and Anuppur in Madhya Pradesh and Bilaspur, Korba, Koria, Raigadh and Surguja in Chhattisgarh. SECL has claimed total sales worth Rs. 7127.19 crores during the same year, and earned a pre-tax profit of Rs. 1,286 crores (post tax profit = Rs. 264.67 crores). One would hail a company with such an impeccable earning record as a shining example of the robustness of the fast shrinking public sector in India. But a team of committed citizens have begun shining the torch of RTI on dark deeds within SECL seemingly buried away underneath mountains of coal dust.

Sunil Chaurasia and Narendra Devangan both belonging to Anuppur, Madhya Pradesh and Satish Gupta of Manendragarh from Koria district of Chhattisgargh filed RTI applications with the PIO of SECL situated at its head office in Bilaspur during the months of February – April 2006. They sought the following information–

1) Names of all medicines procured by SECL for distribution through its primary health centres and its OPD clinics in the Hasdev coal mines area during the financial year 2005-06. (They cater exclusively to the employees of SECL and their families)
2) Quantity of medicines procured during the same period.
3) Supply price of each item.
4) Copies of all purchase orders issued by SECL for these medicines.
5) Name and contact details of suppliers who bagged the purchase order.

All three applicants received the requested information within the 30 day deadline stipulated in the RTI Act. The records showed that SECL had issued two purchase orders worth a total of Rs. 4,47,422/- to a certain R S Trading Company on 02 November 2005 for supplying ayurvedic medicines such as rajwadi chyawanprash, basant kusumakar ras, svarna bhasm, massage oil, divya hair oil, sona-chandi chyawanprash, shilajit capsule, paurush jeevan capsule, chintagani ras, makardhani vari and many other ayurvedic items :
(P.O.#SECL/HSDArea/MMW/SO/05/06/Ayurvedicmedicines/479 and P.O.#SECL/HSDArea/MMW/SO/05/06/Ayurvedicmedicines/480).

Two more purchasing orders were issued on the same day to two more companies namely, Messrs. Sampath Kumar Lakshminarayan of Manendragarh in Chhattisgarh (P.O.#SECL/HSDArea/MMW/SO/05/06/Ayurvedic medicines/482 ) and Soni Medical Store of Dhanpuri in Madhya Pradesh (P.O. SECL/HSD/MMW/SO/O5/06/Ayurvedic medicines/481) for supply of ayurvedic medicines worth – Rs. 99,786.90 and Rs. 1,20,387.50 respectively. Apart from the medicines mentioned above these companies were asked to supply jhandu soap herbal, trishul tablets, kamoddeepak churna (can it be any more explicit than this), sundari kalp forte, rose water and the commonly used disinfectants like savlon, dettol and phenyle. All P.O.s had been signed by the Chief General Manager.

Armed with these documents our RTI trio worked for several weeks crosschecking the data along with a team of about 25 committed volunteers. The P.O.s issued to R S Trading Company mentioned its contact details as a shop situated behind State Bank of India at Manendragarh, Chhattisgarh. Satish scoured the entire area but did not find any trace of the supplier. Soni Medical Store turned out to be a small retailing store operating on a floor space of 10ftx10ft and the salesperson had no clue about the supply of such a huge order. Fictitious companies were shown as suppliers of luxury items in the name of procurement of medical supplies.

Next, the volunteers cross checked the rates at which the medicines had been supplied only to find that the retail outlets sold the same items a lot cheaper. Given below is a comparative table of the retail rates and the rate at which the medicines were supplied to SECL:-

Item Size Retail rate in Rupees SECL Supply Rate in Rupees
Amrutanjan balm 10gm 15/- 20/-
Kayam churna 100gm 33/- 46/-
Paurush Jeevan capsule Strip of 10 20/- 28/-
Sesha hair oil 100ml 88/- 185/-
Sona chandi chyawanprash 1kg 185/- 280/-
-do- 1/2kg 105/- 155/-
Rose water 30ml 10/- 15/-
Banphool oil 200ml 68/- 96/-
Noorani oil 100ml 30/- 44/-
Jaitul oil 50ml 30/- 35/-
Rajwadi chyawanprash 1kg 340/- 440/-
-do- 1/2kg 187/- 250/-
Aglari 100ml 33/- 47/-
Savlon 100ml 23/- 25/-
Dettol 100ml 17/- 21/-
Phenyle 500ml 33/- 56/-

Only one item, namely, Trishul tablets were supplied at a price lower slightly lower than the retail price (Rs. 8/- and Rs. 10/- respectively). During 2005-06, SECL had allocated Rs. 99,78,690/- for its medical budget. The total value of the four purchase orders released under the RTI Act was Rs. 6.67 lakhs. The extent of money lost due to corruption remains to be calculated.

Sunil published the details of these findings in the Koylanchal Times a current affairs magazine popular in the coal mining belt of MP and Chhattisgarh that he published every month. In August, officials of the Vigilance unit of SECL contacted him to hear learn first hand, the story of the findings of the RTI team. Nothing much was heard for a few months afterwards. Upon making informal enquiries with SECL about the progress of the case Sunil found out that the Vigilance unit had instituted a formal investigation. The Chief Finance Manager and the Materials Manager seem to have been chargesheeted in the case and inquiry proceedings are said to be going on.

Sunil, Narendra, Satish and their team of volunteers are elated at these developments. Their painstaking efforts have awakened potential whistleblowers within SECL. An employee of the company in the Hasdev mines area, who spoke with the activists on condition of anonymity, told them that they had merely succeeded in scratching the surface. Corruption in the procurement of medical supplies is deeper and murkier than what has been unearthed. It has been alleged that several batches of medicines supplied to the OPDs and PHCs are well past the expiry date or will become useless in less than six months. The activists are now planning to request spot inspection of the stock of medicines to verify the facts themselves. They are also planning to apply to the Vigilance unit of SECL under the RTI Act seeking a progress report of action taken on the basis of their findings.

Narrative:- Dr. Rakesh Ranjan, Convenor, MPSAA and Venkatesh Nayak, CHRI

{Sunil, Narendra, Satish and their team of volunteers are all active members of the Madhya Pradesh Suchana Adhikar Abhiyan (MPSAA). CHRI works with the Abhiyan to spread awareness about RTI in Madhya Pradesh.}

Thursday, November 16, 2006

Sandhan Association for Advocacy and Development is an independent, non-partial and non-profitable voluntary organisation working in the field of Right to Information and Electoral Reform.